Roy Lichtenstein, Girl in Window (Study for World’s Fair Mural), 1963. Whitney Museum of American Art, New York. © Estate of Roy Lichtenstein.
Roy Lichtenstein made paintings that looked as though they had come off a printing press. Getting them to look that way took painstaking work.
His comic-book women, with their red lips and immaculate tears, remain among the most recognizable images in American art. They are also easy to mistake for straightforward enlargements of their sources. The Ben-Day dots, heavy outlines and clipped dialogue conceal how thoroughly Lichtenstein altered the pictures he borrowed.
The Whitney Museum of American Art takes up those questions in “Roy Lichtenstein: Like New,” opening October 11. Bringing together roughly 130 works spanning the early 1940s through the 1990s, the exhibition includes paintings, drawings, prints, sculpture, film and four re-created murals. It is Lichtenstein’s first New York retrospective since 1993.
The show’s organizers, curator Meg Onli and artist Alex Da Corte, working with Nakai Falcón and David Crane, are interested in what happens when a picture is copied, altered and shown somewhere new. It is a useful way to look at an artist whose borrowed images became vastly more valuable than the illustrations that inspired them.
The source material
In 1961, Lichtenstein painted Look Mickey, adapting a scene of Mickey Mouse and Donald Duck from a children’s book. That same year, Girl with Ball drew on a resort advertisement. For Drowning Girl (1963), he took a panel from a romance comic, cropped it and revised the text and composition. Its desperate heroine became an emblem of Pop art.
The transformations could be subtle or drastic. Lichtenstein simplified contours, removed background details and adjusted the placement of faces and words. Images devised for quick consumption acquired an exacting formal order. His pictures invited viewers to recognize the originals while making it difficult to see them in quite the same way again.
There is an uncomfortable history behind this work. Commercial comics were often drawn by artists who received little public recognition and did not retain control of their images. Lichtenstein’s versions entered museums and commanded the prices associated with fine art. The fact that he changed the source material does not settle the question of what he owed its makers.
It is tempting to compare that dispute with today’s arguments over images used to train generative AI. There is a family resemblance, particularly in questions about permission and credit. But Lichtenstein selected and reworked individual pictures, while AI systems can be trained on enormous collections. The processes are different, and the analogy only goes so far.
Making the mechanical
The paintings have an almost impudent neatness. Lichtenstein used stencils and carefully planned fields of color to reproduce the look of commercial printing. Yet these were physical objects, not mechanically enlarged comic panels. Up close, the patient construction of their apparently effortless surfaces becomes apparent.
The joke is particularly sharp in his paintings of brushstrokes. For Abstract Expressionists, the brushstroke could stand as evidence of the painter’s immediate feeling. Lichtenstein turned it into an outlined, repeatable shape. The spontaneous gesture had become a graphic emblem, suitable for reproduction.
He pursued similar puzzles in paintings of mirrors, interiors and landscapes, and in versions of works by Cézanne, Picasso, Monet and Matisse. These subjects gave him different ways to test how much visual information viewers need before they recognize what they are looking at.
The woman in the window
The Whitney has used Girl in Window (Study for World’s Fair Mural) (1963) to promote the exhibition. A red-haired woman smiles with closed eyes, her skin covered with red dots. Her features have been compressed into the brisk shorthand of an advertisement.
The women in Lichtenstein’s paintings are frequently treated as stock characters. The tears, telephone receivers and anguished thoughts come from romances in which readers had to understand a character’s predicament in an instant. Some of the paintings gain their odd force from how little access they give us to the person supposedly suffering or rejoicing. A face can declare an emotion without revealing much else.
The show also places Lichtenstein alongside Louise Lawler, Richard Pettibone and Sturtevant, artists who have challenged familiar ideas of authorship. Sturtevant remade other artists’ works; Pettibone painted miniature replicas; Lawler photographed artworks in the places where they were bought, sold and displayed. Their presence gives Lichtenstein’s appropriations a context beyond Pop art’s bright surfaces.
Back on Greene Street
One of the exhibition’s most ambitious undertakings is the re-creation of Lichtenstein’s nearly 96-foot Greene Street Mural, made in 1983 for Leo Castelli’s SoHo gallery. On that scale, the shapes do more than fill a canvas. They occupy and organize the surrounding architecture.
The mural also belongs to a particular New York. Castelli helped establish Pop art’s international market, while SoHo’s converted industrial lofts became galleries and, eventually, coveted real estate. Lichtenstein’s career flourished amid those changes. In a neighborhood devoted to converting things from one use and value into another, his paintings of transformed commercial imagery were thoroughly at home.
Looking again
Lichtenstein’s work has become part of the visual furniture of American culture. The dots and speech balloons appear on posters, clothing and countless imitations. That familiarity can make the paintings seem simpler than they are.
The Whitney’s retrospective offers an opportunity to look past the instantly recognizable style: at the original pictures, the revisions, the painstaking execution and the artists whose work he adapted. His career was not a single joke about comics being admitted to museums. He returned repeatedly to the uneasy distinction between an image and its reproduction.
The paintings are funny, sometimes rather cold, and exceptionally good at holding the eye. Stand in front of one long enough and the slickness begins to give way. The more mechanical it looks, the more you notice the decisions of the person who made it.
“Roy Lichtenstein: Like New” is at the Whitney Museum of American Art, 99 Gansevoort Street, October 11, 2026, through May 10, 2027.
